Talk:The Battle of the Long Day

Page scope and name
I would like to comment personally (not with Administrator authority) with a few thoughts I had on this article. Firstly, I think both the article title and subject should be focusing on the battle itself rather than the "long day". The article's title should reflect the battle with a title containing "The Battle of" or "Battle at" etc. I think at this point in time that the content's of this article should be placed into respective articles (on Gibeon, Joshua,etc) rather than having its own standalone article. Standalone articles on Battles may occur one day, but right now the particular events of a location/people group are usually covered in the article about the subject itself.

I would like to propose either re-focusing the scope of this article (and renaming it), or merging the contents to a relevant article.

In Christ, Superdadsuper, Bible Wiki Administrator and Bureaucrat 17:04, June 6, 2017 (UTC)


 * I can agree with renaming it to "The Battle of the Long Day" or something of that nature. I can also agree with modifying the subject to match the new title. I just don't know if we should merge it with other articles. If we are going to write these articles some day in the future, why not do it now? Maybe not push it immediately, but allow for it. Those are my thoughts  Christian Sirolli ( Talk 20:06, June 6, 2017 (UTC)


 * I'm with Christian SouthWriter (talk) 23:12, June 8, 2017 (UTC)